S3E10: Rocks (Transcript)
Lutz Koepnick: You’re holding two rocks in your hands. Why, why are they special to you?
Jana Harper: Oh my gosh. These two, I love these two rocks. They’re very differently shaped. They’re both very black, but they’ve both been split in such a way that there’s a really clean break, and it reminds me of a drawing I made something like 30 years ago in grad school about- broken pieces, a whole broken into its parts.
Lutz Koepnick: This is artist Jana Harper, my partner for almost two decades, talking about the role of rocks in her artistic practice and how they, when we traveled to Svalbard in the polar north, inspired her to make a whole range of videos, collages, and camera-less photographs. We are standing right next to a glacial riverbed, the water is near freezing. It’s almost midnight, but it’s mid-June, so the sun is still up and it bathes everything in golden light.
Jana Harper: These rocks embody, something I’ve been thinking about for a long time.
Lutz Koepnick: Are you contemplating to take them along?
Jana Harper: Yeah, and I never, never Take things from where they’re from
Lutz Koepnick: Why is that?
Jana Harper: because I learned a lesson a few years ago that has really made a huge impression on me that things have a home, objects have a home, and that when you displace them from their home, you are disempowering them. You’re taking their agency from them. And everything that they know, and then, like, do you really care for them or do they just sit on a shelf? I don’t know. It’s a
Lutz Koepnick: They are beautiful
Jana Harper: Tell me what you see. Just you describe them
Lutz Koepnick: One is long, longer, much longer than wide, and the split is really very unevenly split in that just a tiny little fraction on the right side has split off from the major part. The other one is more like, hmm, when it was together, maybe more like a- Teardrop shape… like a teardrop, like a pear. And it kind of split quite in the middle, not all the way through, but quite in the middle, so the pieces are not quite equal in size, but, very different break than the first one. There are dark gray, there are almost black. there are some residues of mud on them, and when you look at the fracture, you see layers within this very thin stone, different kind of bands and lines that are mostly black, but also some of them more gray and white. But now that you’re turning them away from the northern sun, I cannot see those anymore.
Jana Harper: I am trying to photograph them.
Lutz Koepnick: In the last two episodes of Art of Interference, I took you on a journey to Svalbard, way up in the Arctic North. We explored how art might offer different ways of responding to the challenge of living—and creating—after the end of coal: after the mining of the fossil carbon that has powered life on this Arctic archipelago for more than a century. Today, we shift gears a little. This is the final episode of our third season of Art of Interference, and we’re returning once more to Svalbard—to the echoes of a research trip that visual artist Jana Harper, filmmaker Jonathan Rattner, and I took there last summer. But this time, we’re taking our cues from Svalbard’s rocks, its geological formations, and the traces of histories they carry. And rather than discuss life after coal, today we’ll explore tension that increasingly shapes contemporary life: the tension between geological deep time and our own culture of speed. Artist Jana Harper will join us again, along with geologists Lily Claiborne and Dan Morgan, and intellectual historian and literary critic Noah Heringman. Together, we’ll ask what rocks might teach us—not about Earth as a timeless entity, but about Earth as timeful, a living planet. Timefulness. At first, that might sound like a somewhat strange term—especially at a moment when we’re confronting accelerating planetary change and global overheating. Shouldn’t we be craving more timelessness instead? Shouldn’t we want to stop—or at least slow down—the frenzied clocks of change? To freeze time, somehow, to protect what is melting? The term timefulness isn’t mine. It comes from the geologist Marcia Bjornerud, whose work I greatly admire. Here’s how she explains it:
Marcia Bjornerud: Everywhere, the natural world is bursting with backstories. The world is made of, or more precisely, by time. This is what I mean by timefulness, an awareness of the rich natural history that envelops us, a sense that we too live in geologic time, and are part of a continuum from the planet’s past into its future. Timefulness is a deliberate counterpoint to timelessness, an unattainable, sterile, and I will argue, even dangerous idea.
Lutz Koepnick: Bjornerud’s notion of timefulness alerts us to the fact that life on planet Earth exists because planetary history unfolds across many different narratives, rhythms, and temporal scales. They inflect one another. They often rub up against each other in complicated ways. But in all their plurality, they also far exceed the range of time that modern humanity has claimed as its own: the time of progress, of history, of human meaning. Timefulness, then, challenges our many efforts to subject the diversity of planetary time to our own needs and desires, to our own expectations and schedules. It asks us to reconsider our attempts to remake Earth’s time in our own image—and, in doing so, to unsettle the complex temporal interactions among different forms of life, geological processes, and Earth systems.
Marcia Bjornerud: Even though we will spend our entire lives here, we behave like bad tourists on Earth, enjoying its amenities and ransacking its bounty without ever having noticed that it has its own ancient language and customs. Many of the environmental problems we face have arisen because we collectively lack a sense for the duration of chapters in Earth’s history, the rates of geologic processes like groundwater flow, or the intrinsic timescales of natural phenomena like climate change.
Lutz Koepnick: So what does this mean for art? What kinds of images, stories, and practices can help us experience these vastly different, yet overlapping, scales of time? In this episode of Art of Interference, we explore what happens when art encounters geology—what we can learn from both about rocks, what they can learn from each other to ask tough questions about our changing planet, and what both might teach us about living again in the present of deep time and about the art and science of rediscovering the value of timefulness.
PART ONE: CONVERSATION I
Lily Claiborne: I am Lily Claiborne. I’m a geologist broadly, but an igneous petrologist. And what that means is that I am interested in magmas and the magmas that feed volcanoes or that sort of die in the crust and don’t end up feeding a volcano. But I’m really interested in how magmas are produced, how they change, where they’re stored in the Earth’s crust, how they change over time, how they move around, all before we see them at our surface. And in order to understand those materials and processes, I use the rocks that those magmas eventually become. And I look at the chemistry and the textures of those rocks and their orientation to one another in the field to tell the stories of each system’s history that I look at.
Dan Morgan: I’m Dan Morgan. I’m a glacial geologist, and geomorphologist. I’m really interested in landscapes and the processes that create hills and valleys and sometimes how giant mountains are eroding away. And I focus a lot on the terrains and the landscapes that glaciers create. I’m really interested in figuring out like when were glaciers bigger, how fast do they change size and shape over time. ’cause that helps us understand like how does climate normally impact glaciers and what’s going to happen to glaciers in the next 50, a hundred, five hundred years,
Jana Harper: i’m Jana Harper. I’m a visual artist. I work across many media, on many different subjects, but I will say that a few of the subjects that unite my work are politics in US history, having particularly to do with Native American history. And I also collaborate in that capacity with a very specific island in Lake Huron called Mackinac Island. So I’m working collaboratively with landscapes but I’m also working with, conceptual strategies to have conversations in art about larger. Natural and political questions.
Lutz Koepnick: One of the things that has brought us together here is work that you’ve done, Jana, with rocks in Svalbard in the Arctic. Rocks are often seen as very timeless maybe even numb, maybe even dumb static objects we think of them. They exist outside of time. They don’t really tell stories to most people. But in the work that you all three have done rocks, I can imagine, tell all kinds of stories.
Lily Claiborne: One of my favorite geologic authors says, rocks are verbs. And I find this to be true. I get frustrated when in literature or in art rocks are used as this sort of solid, unchanging permanent thing because I think of them very differently. When I look at a rock, I see layers of stories that it tells for a rock that’s formed from a magma, there’s the story it tells about the magma. If you’re looking at a piece of a rock, there’s the story of how it came to the surface. From where it first became rock, to then was brought to the surface, and then how it might have been moved and shaped by surface processes to a whole other place. A rock doesn’t even just tell one story. It can tell layers of stories across huge amounts of time. And the stories I tell mostly have to do with these sort of magmatic plumbing systems in the crust that we never see. We can never see them, we will never be able to see them. We can use all kinds of tools to try to image them, but all of it’s imperfect. And so they tell us stories that are otherwise inaccessible to us.
Lutz Koepnick: Dan, you brought a lot of rocks to this conversation, and I’m sure they tell all kinds of different stories.
Dan Morgan: So like Lily said, I, the rocks tell you a lot of different stories, and I think that’s the thing that always appealed to me about them is that they could tell you like, Where did they come from? When were they born, as it were, and the magmas, and the pressures and temperatures that created them? How did they get to where they are today? What processes brought them there, what’s been happening to them since then? How long have they been there? As an undergraduate, really fell in love with this idea of like, all right, let’s figure out. How did we get here? What’s going on now? Where are we going? So I, those big picture questions were always the things that inspired me as a student and that I like thinking a lot about today. And I’m particularly interested in the stories. I lumped them into sort of dates and rates, right? So I’m really interested in like how long have rocks been on the surface? What processes brought them there? Was it a landslide or was it a glacier or a river flood? What tools can we use to figure out, how old are these surfaces? How long have these soils been developing? What does that tell us about how quickly did the glaciers change? Or how often do floods or landslides or hazards happen? And so really trying to figure out those stories of, that are mostly about, all right, when do they happen? How fast do they happen? How frequently do they happen? Those dates and rates. I’m really interested.
Jana Harper: In my work with Mackinac Island, I, at one point I was very interested in these Indian censuses from the turn of the last century and had a curiosity about who remembered those people or who remembered those names and I went around the island seeking out geologic formations, trees, features in the landscape that I felt had been there as long as those people and read the names out loud. So there’s a rock called Sugarloaf that’s in the center of the island that’s a tourist attraction, but I went at sunrise and read all of the names and it takes about 20 minutes to read all the names. And then that project led to a project at the Smithsonian where I started thinking about the displacement of objects and about the institutionalization of objects and how they get removed from their homelands. And so I went to the Smithsonian, and I found every single thing across 13 different areas that all originated on Mackinac Island. And I went and I visited them and then brought them all together and then brought tribal elders. And we had a ceremony for reuniting and remembering all of those objects. The philosophy behind that work has to do with acknowledging that we’re all from somewhere and that when we’re displaced from where we’re from it’s important to remember. And so when we were in Svalbard we were staying next to a glacial river bed. And we were spending, I don’t know, 14, 15, 16 hours outside a day because there was 24-hour sun. And I happened on all of these rocks that seemed like they were perfectly split in half. It was just where my curiosity led. I just wanted to spend all of my time in that riverbed. Handling those rocks and playing with them and taking the puzzle rocks apart and putting them back together. And then we started filming those gestures of play. And I think that one of the pleasures of art is that it can be rooted in play and that play doesn’t necessarily know where it’s going… The play was just genuine curiosity at work.
Dan Morgan: There’s somewhat a connection to science, right? When we’re involved in it, there, there’s an element of play. And we don’t know the outcome and we don’t know what the solutions might be, and maybe we should try this or that or see what comes about. And there’s certainly an element of that in our work.
Lily Claiborne: That reminded me exactly of what we do in the field. You’re there to look at one thing, but you see everything. And I think probably all sciences, there’s an element of that. But I do feel like field sciences, especially where you’re wandering around in nature, looking at things, there’s so much to see and be curious about.
Dan Morgan: And they’re complicated systems and that element of play is really important. It’s saying could this be happening? Could that be happening? What if, has anyone asked this before? And yeah, that, that curiosity, that playfulness is really valuable and and just exploring and learning more about what’s going on Earth.
PART TWO: JANA HARPER’S ROCK VIDEOS
Lutz Koepnick: That element of play…
Rocks, of course, have a long history in art—as objects of representation and as media of creativity. But for me, this history becomes especially interesting when artists challenge our tendency to think of rocks and stones as numb, inert, and silent, and instead draw our attention to them as entities that vibrate, resonate, and transmit or even generate sounds our ears aren’t always equipped to hear. The Italian sculptor and muralist Pinuccio Sciola explored this idea through his pietre sonore, or “sounding stones,” in the second half of the twentieth century. Working with Sardinian limestone and basalt, Sciola transformed large stones into musical instruments. By rubbing smaller rocks across their surfaces, visitors could draw out different tones and vibrations. Sciola described this as liberating the stones’ unheard voices—listening, in a sense, to the voice of the Earth itself. More recently, the Lebanese artist Tarek Atoui has used rocks and stones as instruments for listening to our globalized world. In his exhibitions, altered boulders transmit vibrations recorded or produced elsewhere. Visitors place their hands—or sometimes their ears—against their surfaces. Listening becomes multisensory: through the stone, sounds from another place or moment become physically present, allowing us to travel across space and time. And then there is Deborah Stratman’s 2023 experimental film Last Things. Stratman approaches evolution and extinction from the perspective of rocks and minerals, shifting our attention from human history toward the immense geological timescale of the Earth. Combining science, speculative fiction, microscopic imagery, and landscapes, the film asks us to imagine rocks not as a passive backdrop to human life, but as witnesses to a world that existed long before us—and may continue long after we are gone. Jana’s rock videos from Svalbard resonate with this tradition. Well after our return, I sat down with her in our kitchen to discuss the films she made there about rocks. As I mentioned in the last episode, Jana and I are partners. So I can ask her questions others might shy away from—and may have to avoid some that others would find perfectly natural.
What fascinates you about rocks.
Jana Harper: That’s such a hard question to answer because I think I have always loved rocks. And, You know, I think about how children can have a fascination with rocks., they’re everywhere. They’re all around you. They’re so varied and beautiful and, everywhere I go, I pick up rocks, and I always have. I think there’s just people that are rock people, people that collect rocks and are fascinated with them.
Lutz Koepnick: Do you think they tick differently than non-rock people?
Jana Harper: I don’t know. I imagine that there are tree people and that there are grass people and that there are, you know, people that are sun people.
Lutz Koepnick: I know you’re also a tree person, and I know that you talk to trees. Do you also talk, do you also talk to rocks?
Jana Harper: Oh, that’s a funny question.
Lutz Koepnick: Do you listen to rocks? Do they have stories to tell?
Jana Harper: They have stories to tell, but I think one has to listen to them very differently than one listens to trees. And so when we were on Svalbard, I started to notice these rocks that were split, like perfectly split in half And for some reason, they just captured my attention and my heart. Like, there was something really tender about encountering these broken rocks who didn’t look broken. I mean, they looked perfect until one disturbed them and realized that they were broken either in half or in parts, or that those parts were so close by that they hadn’t traveled very far. And-
Lutz Koepnick: For many people, rocks– or they’re fascinated by rocks because they seem to represent timelessness, sort of history that doesn’t change, sort of stability, endurance. we’re fascinated because, to these rocks because they actually seem to have a history. They seem to change. They sh- they, they weathered or withered in time. There’s something about that
Jana Harper: Well, I think in the landscape of Svalbard, and particularly that glacial riverbed, time is always present, a sense of time And I think you’re aware of how rocks move with the glaciers, how rocks move with the moraine, and you can’t help but wonder where they’ve been and where they’re going, how long it took for them to form, and under what circumstances they could break so perfectly. I mean, one imagines the immense pressure that all of that ice and movement must place on them But for them to break like that was really curious to me.
Lutz Koepnick: Mm-hmm. So rocks aren’t just immobile. Rocks aren’t just timeless and steady. They respond to their environment. They sense their environment. They register their environment
Jana Harper: Some people believe that, yeah Some people believe that rocks are alive
Lutz Koepnick: Do they have perception?
Jana Harper: We don’t know if they have perception, but they could
Lutz Koepnick: Just different than ours
Jana Harper: Very different than ours And it’s perhaps worth treating them as if they do have perception Do we treat trees as if they have perception? It’s been proven left and right that they have perception, that plants have perception
Lutz Koepnick: Have intelligence
Jana Harper: That they have intelligence.
Lutz Koepnick: Okay. Let’s look at some of the videos that you shot there or that you brought home from, from Svalbard. Some of them have been set for display purposes, for exhibition purposes already to some music. But, I think you have a plan to change some of that music or sort of make it more complex and more diverse. So at this point, let’s just look at the raw version and you tell us a little bit of what, what you actually see, what you did there, what we could see in the final version thereof
Jana Harper: We’re looking at a Two screen projection Shot from the point of view of my eyes looking at my hands holding, one rock on one screen and one rock on the other screen, and the riverbed is in the sort of near background
Lutz Koepnick: Slightly out of focus…
Jana Harper: slightly out of focus. they were shot pretty late in the evening. when we were in Svalbard, it was in the period of 24-hour sun, and the sun would slightly dip behind the mountain range, but it never set. And so that kind of beautiful golden light, that one loves in the fall or encounters in the Southwest, that golden light was present for many hours between, like, I don’t know 10:30 and 1:30 in the morning. On one screen, there is a rock that is perfectly split in half, and I’m holding it and sort of caressing it. And on the other screen, there’s a rock that Has multiple parts, that eventually fall into the riverbed. the scene has shifted now. We’re basically looking at the, the glacial riverbed and, the rock that’s split in half. I’m scraping it and rubbing it with a lot of vigor. I guess I was wondering to myself if, if my– if the force of my body could enact any amount of change on it, which it actually couldn’t. and that rock kind of fits Now we see a very, very tiny rock. and I’m holding it in such a way that you can’t see that it’s split And then And then I open it
Lutz Koepnick: as if by surprise
Jana Harper: Yeah. I have to say, when I look at this film, When I look at this film, I experience the same sense of delight and wonder that I experienced when we made it.
PART THREE: CONVERSATION II
Lutz Koepnick: We showed Jana’s rock films from Svalbard to Lily and Dan, eager to find out what they as geologist thought about these curious rocks and what kind of forces may have caused their fractures
Dan Morgan: They’re probably related to it. Warming and cooling, sun’s going around. Seasons are warming and some little natural flaw in that’s started to split. And then once there’s a little crack, all right, it’s easier for it to grow and grow that way. And so especially in a lot of polar environments where. You’ve got pretty extremes between the seasons. And then you also get these time periods where the sun might be up the whole day, but you get pretty big changes in temperature or just seasonality. Yeah, you’ll get lots of rocks that have cracked because of that, and they’re warming and trying to expand. They’re cooling and contracting. And one of the interesting things that I think a lot about is that rocks are, they’re pretty strong if you squeeze ’em and compress ’em, but if you pull ’em apart. They’re surprisingly weak. It’s not easy to just take a rock in your hands and pull it apart, but geologically it’s when they’re getting pulled apart that they’re more fragile and they break more easily.
Jana Harper: There were two very different types of rocks that were that we were encountering. One was a bit smoother, one was a bit rougher, one seemed to break not like shale, but it had a almost like a memory in its growth. Yeah. That it split along. Another one seemed more random.
Dan Morgan: That might be related to what are the minerals in the rock? How big are they? How smooth or tiny are they? And is it easy to make a straight line or a more curving feature in ’em? And again, like polar environments are really fun because not much grows there. And so they’re not getting covered up and, but they’re not interacting with plants and animals in the same way. They might be just getting warmed and cooled by just the sun and there’s not much else going on in some of those environments. And so you see these kind of more rare features that, that are developing in them because yeah there’s very little other things happening in these more extreme environments
Lutz Koepnick: For a rock to become, you called it earlier, puzzle rock.
Dan Morgan: That, yeah. Puzzle rock.
Lutz Koepnick: How long does it take for a rock to become a puzzle rock?
Dan Morgan: It’s going to vary, right? I mean they’re like a lot of our, as it depends, right? But, so a lot of those things are rocks that have been sitting on the surface, sometimes thousands, hundreds of thousands, maybe even millions of years. And these cracks are slowly coming and going, right?
Lutz Koepnick: What did it mean to hold that rock, that puzzle, rock in your hand and start to put it into play,
Jana Harper: I think that the natural metaphor that you make has to do with our own brokenness. Know, not that I was anthropomorphizing, but my mom had just died. I was grieving, I was thinking about. Parts and holes. And I also felt this incredible tenderness towards those rocks. Like they were friends. The experience of tenderness is something I’m interested in generally as a counter narrative to the kind of crassness that we find in so many places. And I think that when you’re spending days and hours in the natural world, it’s really easy to develop an empathy with the world and feeling your own smallness and insignificance.
Lutz Koepnick: I’m curious about what geologists say about empathy with rocks.
Lily Claiborne: I’m always horrified when somebody’s digging up a bunch or knocking down a cliff or, any kind of human development that impacts the rocks. I am sad because there is a sense of loss of something so much. Larger, deeper, longer than any of us. Think about we can’t really fathom and we just in an instant can change it. But I do think I feel a little differently than you do maybe about the, these puzzle rocks because that is already not a hole to me. That is a piece, a very small piece of something that was big, a bigger piece, and then a bigger piece of something that was larger that was underground. And now there are two rocks. And so those, that’s just two pieces now. Two holes that will become smaller and smaller and become grains of sand that will then go into the ocean and go back down into the mantle and come back up as a new rock. So I think the cyclicity that we are aware of and the sort of continuing cycling of materials also affects the empathy we might have because we expect them to change just not on a human time scale. But the change is expected and a part of what happens.
Dan Morgan: There’s a scientific empathy these are my samples. I gotta protect ’em. I want to make, I gotta ’em, put ’em in the right bags, get ’em dry. What do I need to do to make sure I get the right data out of ’em? I gotta take care of ’em, make sure I get ’em back. They’re valuable, they, but it’s that partly it’s that value in those stories they’re telling. And I want to tell the story of these samples and. Yeah that empathy comes a little bit of this is an important story. It needs to be shared. I want to, I want this rock to be known, right? I want these stories told.
Jana Harper: I just wonder what kind of conflict you feel between Dan and Lily in nature and Dan and Lily as scientists in nature, and if there’s any gap between those two experiences.
Lily Claiborne: Sometimes I see some conflict in the way in which science is done or expected to be done in the modern world with the funding and the requirements versus, the ability to really play and to move slowly enough to experience the things you might naturally wanna experience or do when you’re in the field. When you’re doing science, you have a list of tasks, of things you have to get done, and you have a limited amount of time. The boat leaves, and a certain date and you have to go. And so I do think there is some conflict there.
Dan Morgan: I’m not sure I can put this very elegantly, but as a scientist we want to be empirical, we want to make observations, we want to think about the physical relationships or laws, what’s happening with physics and chemistry that’s actually interacting? But you also need to be somewhat open-minded. We don’t necessarily know everything. We don’t have all the tools to measure things and that, yes, there may be something else going on that we can’t observe right now, or we don’t have the methods to see what is going on… so when you say like empathy and things, it’s I don’t, I’m not sure that I’m willing to go to like rocks are conscious and things, right? But it’s but there may be something going on that’s there that we can’t observe yet. And I’m, I. At least willing to be a little open-minded though. Yeah… The empathy stuff I find really interesting in today’s world though, and especially as we’re more and more digital and more and more mechanized, we think about generative AI kind of things and what does it mean to be a human? And one idea that is certainly out there is all right it’s empathy. And then that ability to connect and think and put ourselves in other people’s or other things, perspectives and think that way is a very. Human thing and something maybe the robots won’t be able to do or can’t recreate in the same way. So I get excited when you start talking about empathy. ’cause it makes me feel very human and alive and think about that. When I think a lot about environmental issues and things, empathy is that primary emotion that, that comes to me.
Lutz Koepnick: I’ve seen Jana being very hesitant bringing rocks home and I think none of the rocks that you worked with up in Svalbard have been on the plane to come home. Because you might feel that you shouldn’t dislocate them. Do you ever think about that? What happens when you move your rocks? To different places,
Dan Morgan: there’s certainly a growing awareness of the ethical issues around some of that. And should we be taking all these samples out? What can we do in place that might not disturb anything? Break anything? Are there different measurements or tools we could use that, that don’t do that?
Lily Claiborne: I certainly don’t wanna destroy any. In place outcrops that are, that that I don’t have to sometimes we have to because that’s how we answer our questions and try to do it in places that are unobtrusive and such. But I do think this perspective has an effect here because those rocks will get moved to somewhere else. In some ways we are a part of the natural system. Animals may move the rocks, wind may move the rocks, water may move the rocks, the tectonic forces may move the rocks, and the humans may move the rocks as well. I certainly think it’s important to not be destructive, but I think I am and not take what you don’t need. I use my rocks for teaching. And share them with students, and I think that’s valuable. But I may think about it a little differently because I think of them as constantly moving, changing, becoming something else. Anyway,
Lutz Koepnick: You returned all your rocks that you worked with to the riverbed. Tell us about the reasoning behind that.
Jana Harper: Indigenous knowledge systems, or indigenous studies. Tells us that we need to ask permission. First of all, we need to ask permission to be in a place. If we want to take something, we need to ask permission. And it acknowledges that we’re visitors in someone else’s territory or in another territory. This isn’t to say that one doesn’t ever remove something from its environment that’s not, that’s, it’s not like a never rule. It’s just a question, something to be done thoughtfully. Do I wish I had taken a few of those rocks? In retrospect,
Lily Claiborne: yes. I think so.
Jana Harper: There’s,
Dan Morgan: In a lot of environmental themes and teaching of the concept of restraint is really prevalent, right? We could do this, but do we have to, do, we need to, do we really need, I don’t know, the oil from that wildlife refuge or whatever it might be. And so a lot of environmental things come down to I could, but I’m not going to ’cause I want, I want to leave this in a certain way. And yeah, that. That feeling of restraint and self restraint is really key in a lot of environmental issues.
PART FOUR: JANA HARPER’S ROCK CYANOTYPES
Lutz Koepnick: In one of our previous episodes, we spoke to artist Mary Mattingly about the environmental footprint of photography today and some of her strategies of taking images with greater restraint.
[Quote from Mary Mattingly]
Up in Svalbard, the rocks of the glacial riverbeds inspired Jana to dial up photographic self-restraint: she took images of certain rocks, her favorite rocks, without using a camera at all and exposed these images with whatever she found around her.
Jana Harper: Sure. I used cyanotypes, which uses the sun as the exposure unit. These were store-bought, pre-coated sheets of paper that were small enough that they were easy to travel with. and I placed rocks in the riverbed on them and, used the light of the sun and the exposure, used the river to wash out the paper. so all of the elements that were present, the sun, the rock, and the water, all contribute to the finished image
Lutz Koepnick: You assembled, you sorted the rocks sometimes on that paper in one way or another. What were you trying to– How did you try to constellate this? How were you trying to arrange the rocks? How were you testing, probing things there?
Jana Harper: I think I was trying to make, portraits of the rocks, and I was trying to capture both their brokenness and their wholeness, in different exposures. you know, again, we were talking about strategies that counter-extractive narratives and creating these portraits with cyanotypes felt like another strategy, to do that, a way to create an image without needing to bring the rock home or without needing to, –
Lutz Koepnick: Have a camera?
Jana Harper: Have a camera.
Lutz Koepnick: The concept of photography includes the words light and writing; photography is writing with light. We typically think it’s done with cameras, but you can also do it without cameras. Cyanotypes are one way, one technique, of writing with light without using a camera. Another is of course photosynthesis, the process that makes our plants grow on the Earth and is essential for all life on Earth. Plants write with light when they turn sunlight, water, and carbon dioxide into sugar and oxygen—and thereby produce breathable air and critical nutrition for all kinds of beings. There is no Earth, there is no existence, there is no life on Earth without photosynthesis, this nonhuman or more-than-human technology of photography.
So how do you know how long to expose these?
Jana Harper: Oh my gosh, I wish I knew I wish I wish I’m just looking for the paper to get lighter
Lutz Koepnick: And why do you prefer taking this form of exposure over doing a normal photograph?
Jana Harper: This is a very direct way to make a picture. Essentially it’s just sunlight and the rock, and the paper has held the rock. The paper has been bathed in the glacial water. So the, the paper has all the elements. It has earth, water, and sun in the final image.
PART FIVE: CONVERSATION III
Lutz Koepnick: As rock scientists, as rock artists, you’re all uniquely dedicated to think about things in much larger timescales than most people do you think in thousands and millions, maybe even in billions of years. And I’m really curious to hear more about how that type of thinking inflects your sort of understanding as teachers, as scientists, as citizens of the world
Dan Morgan: One of the things we know as earth scientists that things are always changing. It might look like, all right, earth is static, not much changing, but everything is always changing.
There’s no landscapes where that are totally frozen and nothing changes. And 30, 40 years ago, there was some ideas of parts of Antarctica, though. It’s almost like they’re freeze dried and nothing has changed in millions of years. And then we go there and say, all right, it’s not changing fast, but it is.
Even these really cold frozen places are still slowly changing over time, and it might only be centimeters, every million years, but they are slowly changing. And that’s an interesting Earth history lesson to apply. Like change is inevitable. It will always go sometimes fast. We might have giant disasters.
We get hit by an asteroid. We have an enormous earthquake that might be very slow, and plates are slowly losing, or the wind is just blowing and slowly blasting sand in the landscapes. So the rates might be very different, but they’re always things changing and it’s going to keep changing whether we wanted to or not.
Lily Claiborne: You could possibly see that as a sort of, oh, things are changing, right? And we should expect them to change. But our human habitat has only existed in this one moment geologically that is like this moment. And so it is our human habitat that is at risk, right? The earth will be fine. I, very early in my courses when students write about needing to save the Earth, and that’s not how Earth doesn’t need to be saved. The earth doesn’t need to be saved. It will cycle through. Different kinds of climate regimes and tectonic regimes and things will change immensely. But it is our human habitat that has to be preserved, which has come around and evolved in this moment. And we evolved into it to fit it perfectly. And I think that difference in framing helps me think differently about what we’re dealing with… We do live on a human timescale, and we can change things on a human timescale, but we need to do it within that larger context of those slow rates and long times.
Dan Morgan: You don’t want everyone to become cynics. You don’t want ’em to just give up and be hopeless and say, it doesn’t matter. So it is inspiring them if figuring out how can they enact some change that will help make things better. How can we figure out how to make the planet better for humans, but also maybe everything else has a right to the planet without us interfering in it.
Lily Claiborne: I’ve seen some empowerment in students when they start to understand how long it took to create the habitat that we live in, how complex that development was. How many things connected to one another happened in just the way that they did at just that moment. And therefore why small changes we might make. Are enormous, if folks start to understand how long that river has had that particular pathway, they might think more carefully about damming that river or diverting it
Jana Harper: I think part of what you’re just describing. Is empathy, but it’s in a different form. It’s actually asking students or humans, to just have more respect. And that once you understand time, you have a naturally, a different sense of respect.
Lutz Koepnick: Do you ever listen to the rocks?
Lily Claiborne: We listen to rocks to. Help identify them. And, usually it’s when we’re hitting them with a hammer. But not necessarily to mark them or break them, you can gently hit a hammer up against a rock and if it pings with a certain sound, it’s likely a volcanic rock because they have the glass and the minerals all interlock and are small, it produces a really high pitch sort of ping sound versus some other kinds of rocks that will have a more of a dull thud. And the rocks that are what we call fresh unweathered. We’ll have a very different sound so we listen to the rocks when we’re in the field.
Lutz Koepnick: The original notion of rock music, Uhhuh.
Dan Morgan: , I love ping tests. I’m really interested in young, fresh rocks maybe that a glacier brought on. And so they’re not very weathered and you can identify ’em just by sound in some cases versus here’s something that might be from the previous glacial period. So it’s been on the surface maybe a hundred thousand years longer and it’s more weathered and it sounds quite different. And you can use those simple ping tests to distinguish between the two of them that way.
Lily Claiborne: I teach the students in the intro geology lab. There are a couple of rocks that look very similar. Shale and slate. Slate is slightly metamorphosed shale that’s been squeezed and heated. Not a lot, but a little bit. And it has a very different sound. They can look very similar, but I tell them, hold it up and tap it with your nail.
And one will have a very different sound than the other. So we teach our students to listen to the rocks too and taste them. They have to learn ha about the mineral halite, which is salt. And so they are licking, tasting and listening to the rocks as well as looking.
Lutz Koepnick: Jana, you, when you did the rock work in Svalbard, it made all kinds of noises as well, but was that also a kind of a listening?
Jana Harper: I there was, curiosity, appreciation. And I wouldn’t say it was listening with the ears so much as it was listening with all of the other senses.
Dan Morgan: The vibrations.
Jana Harper: Yeah. I think when we’re curious, we’re listening. But we might be using our eyes, we might be using our hands. We might be having spontaneous questions that arise. So maybe that’s a form of listening.
Lutz Koepnick: You didn’t taste them though, right?
Jana Harper: I’ve been known to taste rocks.
PART SIX: DEEP TIME
The Irish theologian James Ussher was not known for listening to rocks, let alone talking to or tasting them. In 1650, he famously instead calculated that the world began in 4004 BC, on October 23 to be exact. Based on his reading of the Book of Genesis, Earth was only about six thousand years old. Less than two centuries later, geology radically transformed that story. Reading rocks instead of scripture, scientists discovered an Earth whose history stretched across not thousands, but billions of years. In 1981, nature writer John McPhee gave this vast temporal scale a memorable name: deep time. The term describes the immense history recorded in rocks, sediments, continents, and the countless processes that made life possible. And yet, there’s a paradox. Modern science taught us to recognize deep time, while modern life has increasingly become governed by speed, acceleration, and the immediate. Climate change now forces those temporalities back together. Melting glaciers, rising seas, and mass extinction—human-made planetary crises—remind us that human history and Earth history cannot be neatly separated. Geology is no longer simply the backdrop to human history—it has become one of its protagonists. I met with historian and literary critic Noah Heringman, author of beautiful book called Deep Time: A Literary History to explore this paradox, the paradox of deep time in our world of human-made planetary change in further detail.
Noah Heringman: I’m Noah Heringman. I teach at the University of Missouri English. that book is, is the unexpected, the culmination of, what turns out to be a lifelong obsession, with deep time and. The history of it. And so, what I wanted to open up was a literary history that’s captured by a very famous quotation that you often hear when people are talking about. The history of geology. This is a quotation from John Playfair describing James Hutton’s uncanny ability to conjure up epic scale actions from millions of years ago. The mind grows giddy by looking so far into the abyss of time, and the abyss of time is a literary trope. And so with that lineage, a whole literary history opens up. Although I now have moved on to a different book project, I, I keep on writing things about deep time. It won’t let me go. And, I, so I feel like there’s so much to explore.
Lutz Koepnick: If I just think back a few decades ago, sort of where literary criticism, where critical theory and cultural theory was. So concerns about deep time seemed to be way out of time at the time. But some of this has. Changed and you really make strong arguments that maybe has never been more important to think about deep time again. It was an untimely issue, but now it has become a timely issue. Can you talk a bit about the change, that this study of deep time has experienced in, in your own period as well of doing this kind of work, over the last few, years and decades?
Noah Heringman: The most compelling case, I think, has been made by Marcia Bjornerud, who is herself and Earth Scientist, and as far as I can see is the public face of deep time. She writes these beautiful books. The best known of, which probably is Timefulness, in which she coins this term temporal literacy and argues that. This is what is lacking for the reorientation that might generate more sustainable futures. I think that’s very smart. I think it’s very convincing. And one of the things I love about Marsha’s work is that she’s attuned to the storytelling element in geosciences. My most recent piece argues, I think somewhat polemically that the Anthropocene is best understood as a chapter in the reception of deep time. There was the popularization of the con, the concept itself peaking in the 1980s when perhaps it was not something, as you say, that literary theorists, were concerned with. And then in this latest phase of reception, it becomes relevant because. You can’t have the Anthropocene, you can’t have this acceleration if you didn’t in the first place, have deep time against which to set that off. In spite of that, and in spite of the increasing visibility and popularity of deep time. And increasing numbers of articles in popular venues. I feel like it’s still obscured to many people. Do You have this experience or you tell someone I’m thinking about deep time and they say, oh, what is that?
Lutz Koepnick: Or they, they kind of romanticize it as that kind of deep time that still is that other of human time. You start your book with this paragraph, until recently, deep time was defined against human history. Right. And then you, within a paragraph, really make a, a very powerful argument that well, today maybe we start to, due to the effects of the Anthropocene due to the kind of interventions. humans have done to our planetary environments. Now, deep time has come back in a way. We live in deep time again and deep time. I think this is the polemical intervention. Deep time has become a concept, not just with a history, but it is a historical concept, and it has come, it has come back.
Noah Heringman: The Anthropocene relies on deep time for its shock value. The Anthropocene could not be shocking, could not be a crisis if it were not set off against this much longer timescale of formation. It presupposes that timescale and so in a way that that mode of conceptualizing planetary crisis has made deep time in indispensable.
Lutz Koepnick: The assumption was always that there’s the realm of human history and there’s the realm of natural history and for human history to become human history. We have to kind of separate basically from natural history. And that’s what deep time is all about a form of history that is actually different from, it’s the other of human time, but with the Anthropocene some of those borders that were maybe essential for what we call modern times have collapsed. Again, it is part of our own doing. So part of the effects of what we call the Anthropocene, that geological time and human time fold into each other again. Can you unpack that a little bit?
Noah Heringman: I think the distinction becomes problematic in our moment for the reasons that you cite. But it’s indispensable all the same and so it creates a sort of a double bind. Where on, on the one hand we call upon ourselves to show some accountability for anthropogenic changes to the Earth. But at the same time refuse ourselves the comfort of thinking about an unhuman timescale, which deep time in, in some way provided at its inception. So I think there’s that dilemma. We see the necessity for deep time, but at the same time how problematic it can be. I think that, some of the critiques of geological thinking go too far simply because, it’s hard to imagine. Any cultural tradition and in which people are not allowed to wonder about how and when the Earth formed. And what came before human beings. Every culture has a story about that.
Lutz Koepnick: You mentioned the word comfort earlier living in the Anthropocene living. In an ongoing planetary crisis, somehow our standards and our expectations about human comforts probably have to change over time in order to actually stay resilient and alive in many respects. I’m curious about those, those folks that you researched and that you wrote about in the 18th century. When they started to discover deep time, when they started to engage with geological time and natural history. Did they find comfort there or was that, or was that challenging for them
Noah Heringman: That’s a marvelous question. One. Comforting piece of work that the concept did was to open a vista on a human future, potentially much longer than what the human past had until recently been held to be. And so from that respect the idea of deep time is very modern and it’s compatible with the idea of progress. It is also a vast space for the imagination that opens up at a time when symbolic imagination comes to be valued much more highly. Than it had been in the past.
Lutz Koepnick: Your Preoccupation with questions of, deep time is that something that makes you more optimistic or more pessimistic about the future?
Noah Heringman: I have come back around to being more optimistic the Anthropocene is very anthropocentric, right? Speaking just for myself, I need. The temporality of rocks, to keep perspective on that. What, what began as cynicism in my undergraduate days, when Bill McKibben published the End of Nature. I said, oh, nature doesn’t care about us. It’s not nature that it’s ending, it’s just the human population. Forget it, who cares and I then, I spent a long time, you know, trying to be a grownup and, and being attuned, to, politics, which is hugely important. Absolutely the most important issue facing us as a global population, to then making another turn away from that, which is where I am now in dwelling with deep time and seeking some type of literacy, some type of mindfulness to keep that in perspective.
PART SEVEN: CONVERSATION IV AND CONCLUSION
Lutz Koepnick: Noah Heringman’s work makes a strong case that the history of deep time is by no means over. But it also offers plenty of evidence that what we’re often missing today is a kind of geological literacy: the ability to read rocks, to place our own endeavors within much larger historical and planetary timescales—in short, to think like geologists as we approach the many crises of our present. So, I was curious to hear from Lily Claiborne and Dan Morgan about their experiences teaching this kind of geological literacy—and from them, as well as Jana Harper, about what art might be able to do to support it.
Lily and Danny both teach courses on geology, on rocks, on all kinds of earthly matter Is it hard to fascinate young students about these old rocks?
Dan Morgan: Sometimes?
Lily Claiborne: I want to say yes and no.
Dan Morgan: Yeah.
Lily Claiborne: Many of the students we encounter in our courses take our courses because they are deeply concerned about climate, the climate, crisis, environmental problems. Geology struggles a little to attract the students that maybe would have been geologists 40 years ago. ’cause they’re interested in the natural world. Geology is deeply connected to those processes. And so if we get them in the door, they begin to see how understanding these processes helps them understand those other problems as well. But also kids love rocks, man. And so there’s a whole bunch of them that take your class because they always loved rocks. They had a rock collection under their bed when they were five. Their mom, they tell stories about their mom being mad because they brought all the rocks in the house. And and sometimes in lab you still see them that nerd joy comes out when Yeah, when the rocks are out and they’re looking at the, sometimes they’re like, oh, there’s so many minerals. This is so hard. But sometimes they love it. And so I think if we can tap into those two things. It it sparks a lot of interest.
Dan Morgan: One of the things that I’ve always liked about the job and that what we do is that we get to use lots of different forms and techniques and methods in here. Multimedia artists or a lot of social scientists sometimes use mixed methods. Earth scientists and geologists we’re always using lots of different methods and techniques, and that’s one of the things that I think is fun is, alright, some parts of class might be a little boring, but something in that class probably appeals to the students. So there’s, there are lots of ways to try and appeal to the students in the class and usually can find something that they latch onto.
Lutz Koepnick: Thinking back of the work that Jana has been doing in Svalbard, this playful work with the puzzle stones and rocks and the rubbing and bringing them into play, it’s also a laboratory, in a sort of a laboratory setting… Exploring what could happen if I bring different kind of rocks into play, into conversation.
Dan Morgan: Yeah.
Lutz Koepnick: Did it feel like being a scientist.
Jana Harper: No, it felt like being a 5-year-old.
Lily Claiborne: That’s what a scientist do. That’s why we do what we do. I get to have a rock collection still. Yeah.
Jana Harper: That day when we were like rubbing the rocks together, it just seemed hilarious. Yeah. It was like a joke almost because I thought like any kind of rubbing that my two hands were going to do was going to have zero effect on the surface, that interior surface. But it seemed fun to play with.
Dan Morgan: Yeah. Yeah, it is. It probably tells you a bit about how they broke and everything. How smooth or rough was it?
Lutz Koepnick: We often love rocks because they seem so rock-steady: islands amid the rush of time, resilient against change, detached from the world around them—little slices of eternity, of timelessness, amid the speed of the present. But nothing could be further from the truth, once we shift our scale of observation beyond the narrow horizons of human time. It might sound strange to say that rocks listen. That they perceive the world around them. That they resonate with their environments. But if we look from the perspective of planetary deep time, much stranger things could be said about life on Earth, including our own insistence on centering the world around the limited bandwidth of human seeing and listening—around our own temporal needs and horizons. Rocks are never really rock-steady. They are media of time. They are living archives of what geologist Marcia Bjornerud calls “timefulness.” Rocks might not resemble what modern culture likes to think of as self-determined agents or thinking subjects. But as the work we’ve discussed today suggests, they can help us rethink what we mean by agency in the first place. What if agency isn’t simply about individual autonomy, intention, or strategic action? What if it also means being open to the world—blurring the boundaries between activity and passivity, emphasizing coexistence rather than control, receptivity rather than willfulness? To think like a rock—or even, in this sense, to be a rock—would mean asking how much we allow the world to act upon us. To witness and register change not for its own sake but to build transformative bridges across time. And it might mean understanding gestures of vulnerability not as blind submission to what lies beyond us, but as a first step toward a more planetary understanding of freedom: a way of living within, rather than trying to master, the many different times that make up planetary life as we know it.
Thank you for listening to Art of Interference. This episode brings the long journey of Season Three, “Earth,” to a close. It has taken us from sites of lithium mining in Latin America and Indigenous protests against deforestation in Amazonia, to wood artists in the Pacific Northwest; to artists working with soil, salt, and grass near Nashville, on the East Coast, and in the UK; to urban foragers in New York and Liverpool; and, finally, all the way to the Arctic in Svalbard. Next year, we’ll be back with ten new episodes about artists, filmmakers, composers, and performers engaging the element of fire in our time of planetary overheating. We’ll be thrilled if you join us again.
And by “we,” I mean Jennifer Gutman, Tori Hoover, Maren Loveland, Emma Vendetta, and Lutz Koepnick. Together, we’ve been collaborating on Art of Interference for more than four years now. As the podcast moves into its next chapter, Tori, Maren, and Emma will be taking more of a back seat, while Jen and I are in the process of bringing together a new team for what lies ahead. So let me take this opportunity to say, out loud, how tremendously grateful I am for everything Tori, Maren, and Emma have invested in Art of Interference over the years. It has been a true privilege to work with them. Their ideas and contributions, their dedication and their interferences, have shaped this project in ways that are hard to measure—and have been truly transformative.
Art of Interference is produced at Vanderbilt University in Nashville. Today’s episode was written, edited, and mixed by Lutz Koepnick. Be sure to subscribe to the show on the podcast app of your choice. And if you like what you’ve heard, please rate and review us. It really helps us get the word out. For links and more information about the show, the artists, and the experts featured in each episode, please visit our website at artofinterference.com.